View Comments

“Panic Bear” Not Actually Funny

By Akela Talamasca on July 13th, 2009

panicbearI think we can generally agree that it’s wise to teach our kids that teasing, taunting, and bullying are awful behaviors, right? So how, as adults, do we justify committing these behaviors ourselves?

Watch the following clip of a Korean television show (despite the fact that the header text claims it’s Japanese) as a zoo worker takes a young bear and purposefully places it into various other animals’ enclosures just to watch it react in panic and fear.

The bear is obviously terrified — if you can see white around an animal’s eyes, it’s pretty well freaked out. And this continues with at least three separate animals. If I wanted to extend the benefit of the doubt, I’d say that maybe there’s something in the narration that explains this, that bears some merit for what they’re putting that bear through. But listen to the mocking tone of the narrator and the laughter of the audience. This just looks like straight-up cruelty.

Not to mention what the other animals might think of the bear. And shouldn’t a zoo be more aware of preserving an animal’s well-being than the average man on the street? If there are any Korean-speaking readers out there, would you do me a favor and translate what’s being said in this clip? I’d love to be proven wrong about all this.

  • James Acton

    Fucking savages.

  • http://static.kidglue.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/01/bonnie-owens.jpg Bonnie Owens

    This kind of stuff makes me sick to my stomach. When people torment helpless animals or people for their own entertainment I think that it is the lowest form of human action. I make it a point to show my children that this sort of behavior is disgusting and unacceptable.
    The other day we were at a park that has ponds and fishing. We saw a man trying to hook a mama duck who was swimming around with her ducklings. The mama was obviously scared, but couldn’t fly away because she was trying to protect her babies. The guy looked back at us and kind of chuckled like, “isn’t that funny?” I made it clear to him that we didn’t think it was. Then I went into a discussion with my son about what would happen to the mama and baby ducks if the man succeeded to do what he was trying to do. My son concluded, “Oh, that’s mean!”

  • Marcel

    I don’t speak Korean but I asked a friend:
    The zoo is attempting to introduce the bear into co-habitation so that understand life with other animals. Both the bear and lions are under a month old, an ideal time for learning. At that age, co-habitation should be a simple, learning, exploratory experience for both animals that they would have in the wild. Without these experiences, the bear will never be able to live normally. The commentary over the video is meant to be the voice of the bear, saying things like “Don’t come near!” at which the audience laughs. This isn’t torture, it’s documentation that a television studio is featuring to show a bear that can’t adapt.

    Note: Please do not use this video, or ANY as an excuse to make racial comments about different cultures. South Korea is as progressive as Japan or America or the UK. All the commentary here is showing an undercurrent of racism. Don’t let what you don’t understand create an atmosphere of hate.

  • anonymous

    Too late Marcel.

    The only thing I saw was disgusting is the blog is the author’s knee-jerk prejudice and attitude of moral superiority. The bear wasn’t around three different animals, it was around lion *cubs*, a monkey, and a *shadow* on the ground, and was deathly terrified of all three. Now, I’m no animal psychiatrist, but an wild animal that’s afraid of a shadow needs help, and I’ll trust the zookeepers handling it more than I’d trust some bleeding heart blogger 3000 miles away.

  • Kelly

    Dear All,

    I am MD of an organization aimed at preserving bear welfare in South Korea, and I have the privilege of acting as the contact point between SBS, Samsung Everland (the zoo), and WAZA, who regulates zoos worldwide. It is noteworthy that this zoo is a WAZA member. This clip has been acknowledged as ‘disgraceful’ by the zoo, who admits that the behavior displayed in the clip is unprofessional, unethical and in poor taste. As the zoo is in violation of several WAZA ethical policies, an inquiry was sent and the zoo responded with a swift apology. We are requesting a formal written stance be posted on the website of the zoo. For those who see this as ‘educational’:
    This is a zoo. There is no ecological situation in which a bear and a lion co-exist, and animals in captivity are required (by law), to be treated in a manner that mimics nature. No, there is no relevant training occurring, and assigning a human, emotional characteristic to an animal for the sake of entertainment is both ridiculous and ignorant. We find the zookeeper to be unqualified and we regret the positive reception of the clip in South Korea.

    As someone who has the luxury of understanding the Hangul and the context, it saddens me that trained professionals would make such poort decisions.

    For more information, or to express a formal opinion to either party, please contact kelly@moonbears.org.

blog comments powered by Disqus