View Comments

Is Breastfeeding Creepy?

By Tiffany on August 11th, 2010

In recent months, there’s been lots of talk around the issue of breastfeeding:

First, Mother & Baby’s deputy editor Kathryn Blundell shocked many mothers with her confession that she’s pro-formula. In her article she admits that breastfeeding is “creepy” and claims that she made the move from breast feeding to formula because “I wanted my body back. (And some wine)… I also wanted give my boobs at least a chance to stay on my chest rather than dangling around my stomach.” She goes on to say that her breasts aren’t just breasts – they are her very own “fun bags” and part of her sexuality.  “Seeing your teeny, tiny, innocent baby latching on where only a lover has been before feels, well, a little creepy.”

Then, Kim Kardasian slammed women everywhere for breastfeeding in public with this tweet: “EWW I’m at lunch, the woman at the table next 2 me is breast feeding her baby w no coverup,” and last week, we posted about Gisele Bundchen strongly defending breast feeding.

So what’s the deal? As I get older I find more and more women have begun to feed their baby in front of me sans cover-up and I’d have to agree – public breastfeeding is just.. uncomfortable. I mean, I feel uncomfortable when a woman wears a slightly see through shirt, never mind when she’s popped out her “fun bags” for the world to see.  You can’t condemn Paris Hilton for sunbathing naked on a boat in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean and then let loose at your local restaurant. Do I say anything? Of course not – instead I divert my eyes to everything, carry on the conversation, and hope to God the kid isn’t that hungry…

And while there are of course tremendous advantages to breastfeeding your child, to formula feed should not be condemned. In fact, I am happy to say that I was formula fed –

Did I score lower on IQ tests because of it? Most likely.

Did it affect where I am today? Doubt it.

Am I obese because my mother formula fed me? No.

Do I feel like I lack the necessary bond I needed from my mother at birth? Definitely No.

So why feel guilty for it?

While I don’t have a child of my own yet, and have not made the decision myself as to whether or not I would breastfeed – I doubt the hissing and spitting of other mothers in my circle would deter my choice in anyway – and they shouldn’t for you either.

Cheers to Kathryn Blundell and Kim Kardasian for announcing their opinion on such a public forum without fear of what other women would say. Shouldn’t attention be spent less on how to feed to your child and more on whether or not you are?

Thoughts?

Do you think breastfeeding is creepy? Have you ever experienced another mother’s wrath over your decision to formula feed?

  • Caalie

    I don’t think breastfeeding is creepy, and I think if someone has a problem with breasts, that’s exactly what it is: their problem. I know that’s my opinion, some share it, others don’t and that’s fine. You say you’re uncomfortable, but you do what you need to – look away. I have to employ the same tactics with belly buttons – I know that sounds very odd but they make me uncomfortable and so I have to look away, or risk spewing. It’s my problem, I deal with it. But please, let’s not impose our problems on new mothers. Breastfeeding may be natural, but it’s incredibly difficult, and many new mothers aren’t intentionally exposing themselves. And mothers who chose formula do so for many different reasons. What a new mother needs most is support, so let her make her own decision without criticism about what works for herself and her baby.

  • Allison

    Disturbing post. Breastfeeding is natural and not at all creepy. What is creepy is the US mindset of feeding children the most holistic and perfect way possible. Breasts are meant to nurture and feed our young and anyone who chooses to sexualize it rather than see it as a part of our own bodies doing what they are DESIGNED to do needs a reality check.

  • Britney

    I get very uncomfortable when there is someone in front of me breatfeeding. I think it’s great when a woman chooses to breastfeed, I just don’t think it needs to be done in front of an audience. And please don’t use the “it’s natural” argument – sex is natural and you don’t see people doing it up and down the streets. Some things are meant to be done behind closed doors. I want to enjoy my meal without having some woman’s boob in my face.

    I can’t STAND when women are given a hard time for choosing to give their baby formula instead. Forumula babies turn out just fine. No woman should have to be made to feel like a bad mother for choosing the formula route – whether it be for personal reasons OR health reasons.

  • Pwll

    Yeah, I agree. This is disturbing. What happened to make attitudes go backwards like this? Breastfeeding is natural, has been done for eons without mothers feeling like they had to cover up. As far as bottle fed babies turning out fine — if there is a medical problem, then by all means bottle feed, but if you do, cuddle your baby close while you’re feeding her. Otherwise, for the good of the child you should breastfeed. And frankly, as a mother who did, I have to say breastfeeding is wonderful. Wish I had been breastfed, but my mother had me during the forties when it was “not done” unless you were poor. I suffered for it.

  • Renee

    Some women might breastfeed in public by popping out their fun bags for everyone to see, but there are plenty of ways to breastfeed without hiding under a coverup shawl but also without exposing your breasts. Case in point: the picture accompanying this article. Not sure why the kid is naked (!), but her breasts are not exposed. Plenty of women can breastfeed so discretely that all it looks like is that the baby has fallen asleep across their lap. So it’s a little disingenuous to pretend like every mother who is breastfeeding in public is putting on some titillating over the top stripshow.

    Also, there are additional benefits to breastfeeding beyond the ones listed in this article, including the immunities that a mother can pass on to the baby through her milk.

    Getting a baby to latch on, maintaining a good milk supply, etc., is difficult enough for many mothers without trying to shame them into thinking what they are doing is creepy. Of all the reasons people might have for choosing not to breastfeed (and there certainly are good ones), this one is pretty weak and hateful.

  • Allison

    In response to Britney. This isn’t a sexually related “natural” activity. This is about feeding and nurturing your child — something that had been done exclusively up until about 50 years ago. It was the ONLY way to feed a child until recently in human history. So yes, it IS natural.

    It is America that has sexualized breasts and taken away the real purpose of them, to feed a child. To give them the best start in life.

  • Brandise

    I am a breastfeeding mom, and I have the full support of not only my husband, but my mother, her mother, and my sister. It does make my older brother uneasy, but its not like I don’t cover up except when I’m at home!
    I’ve nursed in restuarants, the library, shopping centers, friends’ houses, and nobody has given me a hard time. In fact, most people who saw us, didn’t have a clue what was happening!
    I’ll choose breastfeeding first because I can, because it’s best for my child.

blog comments powered by Disqus